Advanced Search

Editorial Policy

1. Peer Review Criteria

Manuscripts are evaluated according to the following criteria:

• Significance and originality of the research;

• Novelty of the methodology;

• Validity of the data;

• Conclusions that are reasonable and well supported by valid data;

• The manuscript is written clearly and in accordance with the guidelines for authors;

• The manuscript complies with the journal’s ethics and policy.

2. Peer Review Process

The journal adopts a double-blind peer review system, with manuscripts sent simultaneously to 2–3 peer reviewers. In principle, reviewers from the same institution as the authors are recused. Authors may recommend 2–3 reviewers to the editorial office and may also identify reviewers who must be recused. The actual reviewers are ultimately determined by the editorial office.

(1) Initial review: The responsible editor conducts a preliminary check of the submission and submits it to the Executive Editor-in-Chief for review and approval. Based on the subject matter of the manuscript, the Executive Editor-in-Chief assigns the manuscript to the editorial board member responsible for the relevant subject area. The responsible subject-area editorial board member conducts the initial review and recommends external peer reviewers.

(2) Peer review: Manuscripts that pass the initial review will be sent by the responsible editor to 2–3 external peer reviewers for review (reviewers from the same institution as the authors should, in principle, be recused).

(3) Revision: After peer review is completed, authors must revise the manuscript in accordance with the reviewers’ comments, respond to each comment, and then submit the revised manuscript for re-review.

(4) Final review: For manuscripts whose review comments have been returned, the responsible editor compiles the reviewers’ comments and manuscript formatting suggestions and sends them to the responsible subject-area editorial board member for review. The Executive Editor-in-Chief makes a decision on the manuscript based on the external reviewers’ recommendations and the subject-area editorial board member’s opinion: accept, minor revision, major revision, or rejection. The Executive Editor-in-Chief is responsible for the entire content of the journal.

(5) Manuscripts that pass the final review will enter the publication process:

  • Online First: To enhance the dissemination efficiency and utilization value of academic articles, the journal will conduct online first publication for manuscripts that pass the final review and for which the authors have granted authorization. Authors must ensure that the manuscript has been fully revised in accordance with the final review comments and that its format complies with the journal’s template requirements. Online first articles are considered officially published articles. Once published, the article title, author names and order, author affiliations and order, corresponding author, and main academic content cannot be modified.

  • Print Publication: Manuscripts need to go through editing, typesetting, author proofreading, editorial proofreading, and other stages until they meet publication requirements before being published in print. After typesetting, the manuscript will be sent to the authors for proofreading. Authors should only correct errors in typesetting and wording and generally should not make changes to the content.

(6) For manuscripts that do not pass the final review, the editor will return the final decision to the author, and the status in the submission system will show “Rejected”.

To ensure fairness in the review process and avoid any potential conflicts of interest, special-issue manuscripts and submissions by editorial board members and editors of the journal also follow the above review process, and the final acceptance decision is made by the Executive Editor-in-Chief. Editorial board members, editors, and peer reviewers must not participate in the review of manuscripts authored by themselves, their family members, colleagues, or other authors with whom they have a conflict of interest.

3. Appeals and Feedback

If authors have objections to the review comments or results, they may submit a written appeal to the editorial department and send it to the journal’s email address. Authors must provide a detailed explanation and clarification for each review comment. The editorial department will review the appeal as soon as possible after receiving it and provide feedback to the authors. The journal welcomes readers and authors to supervise each other and actively provide relevant feedback to the journal, so as to jointly create a good academic atmosphere.

4. Academic Misconduct Detection and Handling

In order to reduce academic misconduct, the editorial department will use the “Academic Misconduct Literature Detection System for Scientific Journals” provided by CNKI to conduct duplication checks on submissions at the initial review stage, and the repetition rate should generally not exceed 15%. The journal only accepts manuscripts that have not been published in formal Chinese or foreign-language journals. Academic misconduct such as duplicate or multiple submissions, redundant publication, plagiarism, and other misconduct is strictly prohibited. Once any academic misconduct is found in a submission, the manuscript will be rejected, and the author’s institution and other journals in related disciplines will be notified.

5. Correction and Retraction

After an article is published, if unintentional scientific errors are found and such errors do not significantly affect the article’s results and conclusions, the editorial department will publish a correction notice in the journal as soon as possible, detailing the changes made to the original article. If a published article contains serious scientific errors, or is suspected of academic misconduct such as plagiarism or fabrication, the editorial department will issue a statement informing readers that the article is at risk, conduct an investigation, and make the results public. If it is confirmed that the article involves academic misconduct, the editorial department will retract the article and publish a retraction notice.